Topics

Matthew 16:18 — "Upon This Rock"

Scripture Interpretation

Whether 'this rock' in Jesus's declaration to Peter refers to Peter himself, to Peter's confession of faith, or to Christ, and the implications for church authority and papal primacy.

Key scriptures: Matthew 16:17-19

Affirms6
Denies10
Nuanced57
Varies2

Catholic (5)

Orthodox (5)

Mainline Protestant (8)

Evangelical (15)

Baptist (Southern Baptist Convention)

Nuanced

Christ is the rock; church built on faith in Christ; local congregations autonomous

Calvary Chapel

Nuanced

Jesus plays on Peter's name; rock/keys refer to pastoral authority

Christian & Missionary Alliance

Nuanced

Rock = Peter's confession of faith; church built on Jesus as foundation

Christian Reformed Church in North America

Nuanced

Rock = Peter's faith-confession; Church's foundation is Christ himself

Church of the Nazarene

Nuanced

Peter's confession and faith; Christ's church built on confessing Jesus as Lord

Evangelical Covenant Church

Nuanced

Rock refers to Peter's confession of faith; foundational authority, not papal supremacy

Evangelical Free Church of America

Nuanced

Peter's faith as foundation; apostolic office; no papal authority claimed

IFCA International (Independent Fundamental Churches of America)

Denies

Rock is Christ, not Peter; rejects papal authority and Roman Catholic doctrine

National Association of Free Will Baptists

Nuanced

Peter's faith as foundation; church is based on confession of Christ

Non-denominational Evangelical

Nuanced

Peter's confession central; variously interpreted as petrine office vs. rock as Christ

Pentecostal (Assemblies of God)

Nuanced

Rock refers to Jesus or Peter's faith; not papal primacy or ecclesiastical foundation

Presbyterian Church in America

Nuanced

Rock is Christ; Peter's faith/confession affirmed; no papal primacy

Reformed Baptist Churches (1689 London Baptist Confession)

Denies

Rock is Christ not Peter; confession of faith is foundation

The Wesleyan Church

Denies

Denies papal interpretation; rock is faith-confession; Jesus alone is Church's foundation and head

Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod

Nuanced

Rock refers to faith/confession; papal doctrine rejected

Charismatic (5)

Anabaptist (5)

Adventist & Restorationist (5)

Other Protestant (8)

Non-Trinitarian (6)

Latter-day Saint (2)

Unique & Independent (7)

African Independent (4)