Matthew 16:18 — "Upon This Rock"
Scripture InterpretationWhether 'this rock' in Jesus's declaration to Peter refers to Peter himself, to Peter's confession of faith, or to Christ, and the implications for church authority and papal primacy.
Key scriptures: Matthew 16:17-19
Catholic (5)
Eastern Catholic (Byzantine Rite)
Affirms
Matthew 16:18 affirms Peter's role and papal succession as foundational
Maronite Catholic
Affirms
Rock is Peter; papal succession and primacy affirmed
Old Catholic Church
Affirms
Peter as rock foundation; apostolic authority affirmed without papal supremacy
Roman Catholic
Affirms
Peter is rock; papal succession based on Petrine office; Church authority centered in Rome
Saint Thomas Christians (Syro-Malabar Church)
Nuanced
Peter as foundational; episcopal structure honored; not papal supremacy
Orthodox (5)
Assyrian Church of the East
Nuanced
Peter's confession is the rock; church has apostolic succession through bishops
Coptic Orthodox Church of Alexandria
Nuanced
Peter has a foundational role; no papal primacy; conciliar authority supreme
Eastern Orthodox
Denies
Peter has special honor and role; papal primacy is rejected as later Western addition
Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church
Nuanced
Rock refers to Peter and his confession; local church authority, not papal primacy
Oriental Orthodox (Miaphysite)
Nuanced
Peter's confession affirmed; collective apostolic foundation emphasized
Mainline Protestant (8)
Anglican / Episcopalian
Nuanced
Peter's confession is rock; church has apostolic succession through bishops
Calvinist / Reformed
Nuanced
Rock is Christ or faith in Christ; keys denote pastoral authority
Congregationalist (UCC)
Nuanced
Jesus' statement acknowledges church foundation without papal primacy claim
Lutheran
Nuanced
Rock is faith/confession, not papal succession
Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod
Nuanced
Rock is faith; rejects papal supremacy doctrine
Methodist
Nuanced
Matthew 16:18 affirms Peter's role but rejects papal claims and apostolic succession
Presbyterian
Nuanced
Rock is Christ; no papal primacy; Peter's confession and faith affirmed
Reformed Church in America
Nuanced
Peter faith foundational; Christ is chief cornerstone
Evangelical (15)
Baptist (Southern Baptist Convention)
Nuanced
Christ is the rock; church built on faith in Christ; local congregations autonomous
Calvary Chapel
Nuanced
Jesus plays on Peter's name; rock/keys refer to pastoral authority
Christian & Missionary Alliance
Nuanced
Rock = Peter's confession of faith; church built on Jesus as foundation
Christian Reformed Church in North America
Nuanced
Rock = Peter's faith-confession; Church's foundation is Christ himself
Church of the Nazarene
Nuanced
Peter's confession and faith; Christ's church built on confessing Jesus as Lord
Evangelical Covenant Church
Nuanced
Rock refers to Peter's confession of faith; foundational authority, not papal supremacy
Evangelical Free Church of America
Nuanced
Peter's faith as foundation; apostolic office; no papal authority claimed
IFCA International (Independent Fundamental Churches of America)
Denies
Rock is Christ, not Peter; rejects papal authority and Roman Catholic doctrine
National Association of Free Will Baptists
Nuanced
Peter's faith as foundation; church is based on confession of Christ
Non-denominational Evangelical
Nuanced
Peter's confession central; variously interpreted as petrine office vs. rock as Christ
Pentecostal (Assemblies of God)
Nuanced
Rock refers to Jesus or Peter's faith; not papal primacy or ecclesiastical foundation
Presbyterian Church in America
Nuanced
Rock is Christ; Peter's faith/confession affirmed; no papal primacy
Reformed Baptist Churches (1689 London Baptist Confession)
Denies
Rock is Christ not Peter; confession of faith is foundation
The Wesleyan Church
Denies
Denies papal interpretation; rock is faith-confession; Jesus alone is Church's foundation and head
Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod
Nuanced
Rock refers to faith/confession; papal doctrine rejected
Charismatic (5)
Charismatic Movement
Varies
Interpreted variously; often Christ as rock; some accept Petrine succession
Church of God (Anderson, Indiana)
Nuanced
Rock = Peter's faith-confession; Church built on Christ; no papal authority
Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee)
Nuanced
Peter's faith is the rock; Christ's church built on confession of Christ, not Peter
International Church of the Foursquare Gospel
Nuanced
Peter as apostolic foundation; church authority is pastoral, not papal
Vineyard Churches
Nuanced
Peter's faith-confession is the rock; Jesus is the ultimate foundation; apostolic authority affirmed
Anabaptist (5)
Amish (Old Order)
Nuanced
Church built on Christ's confession, not Peter's primacy or papal authority
Brethren in Christ Church
Nuanced
Rock foundation is Peter's faith in Christ; no papal authority
Church of the Brethren
Nuanced
Christ and faith-community are the foundation; Peter's role respected but not papal
Hutterite Brethren
Nuanced
Rock refers to Peter's faith and testimony; authority given to the apostles
Mennonite Church
Denies
Matthew 16:18 refers to faith in Christ, not papal authority or apostolic succession
Adventist & Restorationist (5)
Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)
Nuanced
Jesus affirms faith as church foundation; congregational authority emphasized
Christian Churches and Churches of Christ
Nuanced
Peter's role affirmed; Christ as foundational rock; no papal succession or hierarchy
Churches of Christ
Nuanced
Rock = Peter's faith; Church founded on confession; no papal authority claimed
International Churches of Christ
Nuanced
Peter is foundational apostle; but congregational authority is emphasized
Seventh-day Adventist Church
Nuanced
Peter confession foundational; Christ is true foundation
Other Protestant (8)
Moravian Church (Unitas Fratrum)
Nuanced
Matthew 16:18 affirms Peter's prominence while maintaining collegial church leadership
Plymouth Brethren
Nuanced
Rock is Christ; no papal primacy; Peter's confession and faith affirmed
Religious Society of Friends (Quakers)
Nuanced
Rock is Christ; no papal primacy; Peter's confession and faith affirmed
Seventh Day Baptist General Conference
Nuanced
Peter as foundational; rejects papal primacy; Christ as the ultimate rock
The Salvation Army
Nuanced
Peter faith exemplary; church built on Christ dynamically
True Jesus Church
Nuanced
Peter as faithful believer; church built on faith in Christ as Lord
Universal Church of the Kingdom of God
Nuanced
Rock refers to Peter's faith; Church built on Christ the Rock; authority delegated to Peter
Waldensian Church (Chiesa Evangelica Valdese)
Denies
Rejects papal succession interpretation; Rock is Christ or faith-confession; Peter not supreme head
Non-Trinitarian (6)
Biblical Unitarians
Nuanced
Rock refers to Peter's faith confession, not Peter as infallible authority figure
Christadelphians
Denies
Rejects papal/ecclesiastical authority reading; Christ is the rock; no apostolic succession
Church of God General Conference (Abrahamic Faith)
Affirms
Faith in Christ, not Peter, is the church's foundation; anti-papal interpretation
Jehovah's Witnesses
Denies
Peter not the rock; Jesus is the rock; no papal succession or primacy
Oneness Pentecostals (UPCI)
Nuanced
Peter's role affirmed; emphasis on pneumatic leadership via Holy Ghost
Unitarian Universalist
Varies
No binding interpretation; members emphasize inclusive community building
Latter-day Saint (2)
Unique & Independent (7)
Armstrongism (Sabbatarian splinter groups)
Denies
Peter has no special authority; Armstrongist organization led by apostle
Church of Christ, Scientist
Nuanced
Rock = Truth/spiritual understanding; Church built on perception of divine principle
General Church of the New Jerusalem (Swedenborgian)
Nuanced
Spiritual sense: rock is recognition of divine truth; Peter as truth-bearer
Iglesia ni Cristo
Denies
Rejects papal supremacy; Christ alone is the foundation; church is universal, not hierarchical
Message Movement (Branhamism)
Nuanced
The rock is faith in Jesus's divine nature and redemptive mission
Messianic Judaism
Nuanced
Matthew 16:18 affirms Kepha's role while maintaining Jewish congregational structure
New Apostolic Church
Nuanced
Peter's foundational role affirmed; apostolic authority through NAC apostles
African Independent (4)
Cherubim and Seraphim Church
Nuanced
Peter as foundational apostle; episcopal leadership recognized; varying authority models
Church of Jesus Christ on Earth through the Prophet Simon Kimbangu (EJCSK)
Nuanced
Rock refers to Peter's faith; church built on Christ
Redeemed Christian Church of God
Nuanced
Rock refers to faith confession; Christ is ultimate foundation
Zion Christian Church
Nuanced
Christ is the Church's ultimate rock and foundation; apostolic leaders exercise delegated spiritual authority