Shepherd of Hermas — "Early Christian Text"

Whether the Shepherd of Hermas, an early Christian text widely read in the first centuries, holds canonical, semi-canonical, or no scriptural authority.

Overall consensus85/100

Amish (Old Order)

Amish (Old Order)

Anabaptist

Denies

Early Christian text; not Scripture; not binding on faith or doctrine

The Amish do not regard the Shepherd of Hermas—an early Christian text sometimes circulated alongside the New Testament—as Scripture. While it may have historical or spiritual value, it is not part of the biblical canon and carries no doctrinal authority.

The Amish practice of sola scriptura means that faith and practice are normed exclusively by the 66 biblical books. The Shepherd of Hermas was never part of the Amish received tradition. Its exclusion is uncontroversial: it is simply not Scripture.

Key Distinctions

Canonical status:
Historical value:
early Christian text; some spiritual value but not authoritative
Doctrinal authority:
explicitly excluded; not Scripture

Scripture References

Sources

  • Canon lists from early church; Dordrecht Confession of Faith (1632)