Original Sin

Whether all humans inherit a sinful nature or guilt from Adam's fall, and how this affects the human condition and need for salvation.

, , ,

Overall consensus68/100

Eastern Catholic (Byzantine Rite)

Eastern Catholic (Byzantine Rite)

Catholic

Nuanced

Ancestral sin: inherited mortality and corruption, not inherited guilt

Eastern Catholic theology approaches the consequences of Adam's fall through the concept of 'ancestral sin' (Greek: propatorike hamartia) rather than the Western Augustinian concept of original sin as inherited guilt. Following the Greek Fathers—particularly St. Cyril of Alexandria, St. John Chrysostom, and St. John of Damascus—Eastern theology teaches that humanity inherits from Adam the consequences of his sin: mortality, corruption, and a weakened will prone to sin, but not the personal guilt of Adam's transgression.

This represents a genuine and officially recognized theological difference in emphasis from the Western Latin tradition, though Eastern Catholics accept the Catholic Church's teaching that humanity is in a fallen state requiring redemption. The Catechism of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church (Christ Our Pascha) presents this within full Catholic communion, emphasizing that Christ restores what was lost in Adam. The Immaculate Conception, defined by Rome, is accepted; Eastern theology expresses the same reality by stating that Mary was preserved from the effects of ancestral sin.

Key Distinctions

Doctrine type:
Augustinian — inherited guilt (original sin proper) and corruption; defined at Council of Trent
Free will effect:
will wounded but not destroyed; grace elevates
Infant guilt:
infants inherit guilt; baptism removes original sin

Scripture References

Sources

  • Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§396–409
  • Christ Our Pascha: Catechism of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church (2011), §§222–240
  • St. John of Damascus, Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith, Book II, §30
  • Council of Carthage (418)