Original Sin

Whether all humans inherit a sinful nature or guilt from Adam's fall, and how this affects the human condition and need for salvation.

, , ,

Overall consensus68/100

Amish (Old Order)

Amish (Old Order)

Anabaptist

Affirms

Humanity is fallen and prone to sin; grace and community are needed

The Amish affirm the fallenness of human nature as a consequence of Adam's sin. All people are prone to sin and in need of God's redemptive grace. This conviction shapes the Amish community's strict discipline (the Ordnung) and mutual accountability: human weakness requires communal structures of support and correction.

Amish theology does not extensively develop the metaphysics of original sin. The practical implications — that humans need God's grace, cannot save themselves, and require the support of the community — are the focus rather than Augustinian debates about inherited guilt.

Key Distinctions

Doctrine type:
Anabaptist — humans enter a sinful condition but each person is responsible for own sin
Free will effect:
will capable of responding to grace with God's help
Infant guilt:
infants are not guilty; adult/believer's baptism only

Scripture References

Sources

  • Dordrecht Confession of Faith (1632), Article 2