Matthew 16:18 — "Upon This Rock"

Whether 'this rock' in Jesus's declaration to Peter refers to Peter himself, to Peter's confession of faith, or to Christ, and the implications for church authority and papal primacy.

Overall consensus76/100

Old Catholic Church

Old Catholic Church

Catholic

Affirms

Peter as rock foundation; apostolic authority affirmed without papal supremacy

The Old Catholic Church affirms that Jesus declared Peter to be the rock upon which the church is built. Peter holds a foundational apostolic role and authority. However, Old Catholics explicitly reject the Roman doctrine of papal supremacy and papal infallibility.

Old Catholics affirm apostolic authority and succession but hold that Peter's authority is collegial and shared with other apostles, not monarchical or supreme. This maintains continuity with early patristic reading while rejecting medieval papal developments.

Key Distinctions

Rock referent:
Peter is the rock
Peter role:
rejects papal claims
Papal primacy:

Scripture References

Sources

  • Old Catholic Union Statement
  • Early Church Fathers