1 John 5:7-8 — "The Comma Johanneum"

Whether the Trinitarian formula in 1 John 5:7-8 ('the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit, and these three are one'), found mainly in late Latin manuscripts, is considered part of the original text.

Overall consensus49/100

Hutterite Brethren

Hutterite Brethren

Anabaptist

Nuanced

1 John 5:7 Comma not in earliest texts; Trinity affirmed elsewhere

Hutterites recognize that the Comma Johanneum (the extended phrase about the Trinity in 1 John 5:7) is not found in the earliest Greek manuscripts and was likely a later Latin addition to support Trinitarian doctrine. Despite the textual uncertainty, Hutterites firmly affirm the doctrine of the Trinity, which is grounded in many other clear Scripture passages (Matthew 28:19, 2 Corinthians 13:14, etc.).

The Hutterite position is that while this particular verse is textually suspect, the Trinity is not dependent on it for support. The doctrine is established elsewhere in the New Testament. The Trinity is foundational to Hutterite theology, deriving from the totality of Scripture rather than from any single suspect verse.

Key Distinctions

Textual status:
Comma not in earliest manuscripts
Trinitarian grounding:
Trinity affirmed by broader Scripture
Canonical status:

Scripture References

Sources

  • Peter Riedemann, Rechenschaft (1542)