Mennonites affirm that Christ's death on the cross accomplishes salvation — reconciling sinners to God, defeating sin and death, and inaugurating the new creation. The Mennonite Confession of Faith uses a range of New Testament imagery for the atonement without insisting on a single theory. Penal substitution, Christus Victor, and moral influence models are all present in Mennonite theological discussion.

A distinctive Mennonite contribution is the connection between atonement and discipleship: Christ's death was not merely a transaction but a demonstration of the way of nonresistant love that disciples are called to emulate. The cross is simultaneously the means of redemption and the pattern for the community's life. This 'participatory' understanding of atonement is characteristic of Anabaptist theology.